Published: Apr 09, 2018
It's becoming increasingly accepted that gender is a nonbinary spectrum, which means we're not all relegated to just “male” or “female.” Meanwhile, more and more people are choosing to identify with non-traditional pronouns, gender-neutral pronouns, multiple pronouns, or no pronouns at all.
According to recent studies, approximately 1.4 million Americans identify as transgender and 12 percent of millennials identify as something other than male or female. In addition, in a 2015 national survey, some 33 percent of transgender individuals said that, if given the choice, they would prefer not to be assigned either gender designation.
That said, when starting a new job, it can be uncomfortable to share one's preferred pronouns with a new employer who might make assumptions or, worse, discriminate. Nonbinary workers have reported feeling pressure at their jobs when it comes to their lack of gender designation—23 percent of those polled by The Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law said that they purposefully hid their nonbinary status omn the workplace. And of those who chose to go public, almost 20 percent believe they have lost a job because of their status, and 90 percent believe they have suffered some form of job bias, discrimination, or harassment.
So how do you have that conversation with your new boss? I asked individuals who use nontraditional pronouns how they've shared theirs in previous jobs. Here's what they had to say.
1. Be your own advocate.
"I've been out as nonbinary for more than 10 years, around eight of them openly nonbinary in the workplace," says Jordan, who asked that I only use their first name. "I work in nonprofit marketing and I use they/them pronouns. Notably, I live and work in New York City, where the law protects transgender and gender non-conforming employees. Workplaces in NYC are not allowed to discriminate against employees based on gender identity or expression, and intentional or repeated misgendering is explicitly categorized as harassment. Despite these laws, I've had a very difficult time navigating pronouns in the workplace, and know that non-binary people living places without legal protection often face far worse situations.
"I have worked at three full-time jobs since graduating college and, at each one, put a lot of effort into communicating my pronouns. At each job, there was no formal process in place for communicating gender identity or pronouns, so I had to pave my own path and advocate for myself. In the absence of policy, I've had one-on-one conversations with managers, and then informed other staff through either email or bringing it up at a group meeting.
"Generally, my experiences with individuals have been overwhelmingly positive. Most colleagues are more than happy to respect me and my gender identity and quickly adjust to the new language. I find that most people are genuinely happy to be respectful and to learn about a topic they may not have previously had exposure to.
"However, I have also consistently come across problems with my pronouns not being respected by certain individuals. At one workplace (working for an LGBT organization, no less), the lead rabbi consistently misgendered me for years, and the organization refused to update my paperwork and documentation, even after my name was legally changed. At another workplace, after informing staff of my pronouns through email, I was chastised by management for giving people the 'directive' of using my pronouns, and told that no one is required to use my pronouns, in direct conflict with the law. (HR later corrected this 'misunderstanding.')
"The undercurrent of my experiences is that, while many people are accepting, that can be overshadowed by one or two transphobic people, and that policies and procedures are necessary to create safe work environments for nonbinary people. Had any of the offices I worked at had policies or training for staff, or even simply communicated the law and their expectation that staff use my pronouns, it would have gone a long ways towards making me feel safe and affirmed in the workplace."
2. Make it known that your pronouns are not necessarily just a "preference."
"My pronouns are she/her(s)," says Alison Carville of Carville Communication Consulting. "I do identify as a cisgender female. In my life and times I was looking for employment, no one has had to guess or risk mis-gendering me. But I have many friends who identify as genderfluid and transgender. Many find the term 'preferred pronouns' to be misleading, as the word 'preferred' means you like something better than another. It's like preferring beef to chicken, if you eat meat.
"Pronouns are personal, and trans* and genderfluid individuals have the right to be called by their pronouns, not as a 'preference.' My intention is to come across as sincere, and take some burden off of trans*-identified people to let [people] know how unintentionally harming word choice can be."
3. Be open from the start.
"I've realized that most people are respectful of my pronouns (she/her/her's) and don't want to make me feel uncomfortable; it's just that most of us are wired to 'assume' someone's pronouns based on the way they look," says Bethany, a transgender woman still going through her transition. "I find that if I'm open and honest from the start, the genuine people around me will make the effort to call me by the pronouns that reflect who I am, and they are happy to do so. I usually just casually say, 'Hey, by the way, these are my pronouns and I appreciate if you use them when referring to me,' as soon as I'm introduced to someone new.
"For those who make no effort, I try to keep our working relationship as cordial as possible, but I also try not to let their ignorance affect me or my work. I've been fortunate enough to have never worked for an employer who didn't respect my gender identity, though I have run into some colleagues who seemed quite careless about it."
4. Share in different ways.
"I share my pronouns in a variety of locations: under my name, on their own line, on my CV, and the same in all headings or signatures on documents such as cover or recommendation letters," says An Sasaia, a PhD student in trans*/queer studies who serves on the board of KSTEP, the Kansas Statewide Transgender Education Project. "I remind my advisors which pronouns to use in their letters, and I often include references to my nonbinary gender and pronouns in the letter with a statement such as, 'As a nonbinary instructor, who uses the pronouns they/them and ze/zir," and so on. I also mention them early on in conversations/interviews by asking for a pronoun exchange."
5. Be confident in who you are.
"I always just tell them straight away, 'My name is Brenna and I use the pronouns they/them/their's,' and then I ask them for their pronouns so I make sure not to assume either—if I don't want people to assume my identity, I want to give them the same respect," says Brenna, a New York-based queer rights activist who uses the pronouns they/them/their's. "That said, there will always be people who slip up and there will always be people who ignore your pronouns, but you have to keep confident in who you are. If you find that there are constantly coworkers or managers ignoring your pronoun requests, it may constitute as discrimination in the workplace. I personally don't agree that we should have to quit and find a new job, because the burden shouldn't be ours, but if you feel uncomfortable you should report it to HR and try to do something about it. This is who you are, and that's a big deal. Don't let it fall to the wayside. Be confident in your pursuit of equality."
A version of this post previously appeared on Fairygodboss, which helps women get the inside scoop on pay, corporate culture, benefits, and work flexibility. Founded in 2015, Fairygodboss offers company ratings, job listings, discussion boards, and career advice.
As Pride month comes to a close and we release our latest Law Diversity Rankings, we thought it would be great time to take a look at the progress that’s been made in LGBT equality in the workplace. Below is a list of 10 companies in law, banking, accounting, tech, and other industries that have made great strides in promoting LGBT equality, diversity, and fairness.
It's hard to believe that, under federal law, it's not explicitly illegal to discriminate against employees based on their sexual orientation. However, yesterday, in Chicago, a federal court of appeals ruling went a long way toward outlawing sexual orientation-based discrimination.
Although Wall Street is still considered, in some corner cubicles, to be an “old school,” “Waspy,” “predominantly Caucasian male-dominated” industry filled with “ex-Ivy Leaguers,” it has slowly been growing more diverse with respect to gender, race, and sexual identity. In fact, in the past five years, the industry has gone from not wanting to even talk about diversity issues to downright blasting them over loudspeakers.
For many of today’s law students, firm culture, location, and practice area remain the most important factors in deciding where to apply. Recently, students have discovered that evaluating these factors — and making the right choice for their legal career — is easier when opting to apply directly to firms for summer positions.